High Tea at Vanillamore: Reviews and Photos

A review of High Tea at Vanillamore in Montclair, NJ. It’s a culinary delight, sure to please any palate.

What to Get at Vanillamore

The high tea menu consists of several courses, with carefully crafted tea sandwiches, biscuits, chocolates, exotic teas and more. Note that the high tea selection certainly favors the sweet.

Best Sweet Bite

The cream puffs made in-house had the most delicate vanilla custard. The buttery pastry was flakey and perfect.

High Tea at Vanillamore

Ambiance at Vanillamore

The open-kitchen vibe provides for a fun culinary experience.

Great for Big Groups

I recommend Vanillamore for big groups. There was a birthday celebration next to us at a long table – not only are the acoustics pretty good (so you can hear what people are saying. Gosh, I sound old!) but the place is BYOB so you can keep the cost down when dining with a big group.

Best Bite

My favorite aspect of the meal was the chicken curry sandwich, which was served on a lightly toasted baguette. My only complaint was that there wasn’t more!

Vanillamore high tea

Could Do Without

I wasn’t a huge fan of the smoked salmon toast. I’m a huge lox fan, but smoked lox has a strong and potent flavor already, so pickling it wasn’t my cup of tea but I appreciate the creativity.

Amazing Service

The service was spectacular and the staff were incredibly friendly and seemed genuinely happy to be there.

The overall high tea experience at Vanillamore was excellent and memorable for its unique flavors and creativity. According to chef and owner, Risa Magid Boyer, “Vanillamore was inspired by my love for vanilla and the way that it can be used to enhance other flavors in desserts, just as salt is used in savory food.  The name itself is a play on words – Vanilla + amore – the love for vanilla, as well as Vanilla + more, because there is so much more that we offer than “just” vanilla. At Vanillamore, there’s no such thing as “plain vanilla”. We couldn’t agree more. 

Vanillamore: 349 Bloomfield Ave., Montclair, NJ at 973-707-5373

Vanillamore exterior

About Claudia Marie Russo

Claudia Marie Russo is a Corporate Communications executive in New York City. A graduate of Villanova University, she holds a Bachelor of Arts in Communication and is currently pursuing her Masters of Science in Corporate Communication from Purdue University. In her spare time, she enjoys long days at the beach, attending folk-rock concerts, cooking, drinking wine, eating Margherita pizza and spending time with family and friends. She currently serves on the leadership committee for the Villanova Communication Alumni Network. A New York native, Claudia now calls Weehawken, New Jersey her home, where she lives with her husband and daughter.

You May Also Be Interested In:

Chef Risa Boyer’s Go-To Restaurants in Montclair, NJ Area

Chef A.J. Capella’s Favorite Restaurants in Montclair and NYC

Ilson Gonçalves Favorite Restaurants in Montclair NJ and NYC

About Suburbs 101

Suburbs 101 is an online lifestyle guide for the New York Suburbs of Westchester County, Long Island, Fairfield County and Northern New Jersey.  Get the inside scoop on what it’s really like to live in the New York suburbs through our interviews with local suburbanites and features on Food, Fashion, Home, Travel, and Local Events. Be sure to Follow Us on InstagramLike Us on Facebook and subscribe to our Monthly Newsletter.